Lawfy & Co
A notice under the GST law
A factual note on a show-cause notice under the CGST Act, the difference between the ordinary and the extended periods, and what a reply is for. It is not a method of hiding turnover.
A notice is not the final order
A show-cause notice under the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 tells the taxpayer the demand the officer proposes and the reason. Section 73 deals with tax that was not paid, or was short paid, or was wrongly refunded, or input tax credit that was wrongly availed or used, for a reason other than fraud, wilful misstatement, or suppression. Section 74 deals with those same consequences where one of those reasons is alleged. The time limits, the penalty, and the chance to pay before the order are different in the two sections. Reading a section 74 notice as if it were a routine mismatch is a mistake. Treating every mismatch as fraud is also a mistake, when the notice itself does not allege it.
The taxpayer is entitled to a reply and, where the law requires it, to a personal hearing before an adverse order. An order that ignores a reply that was actually filed is open to challenge. A reply that does not answer the annexures is easy to ignore. The returns, the invoices, the e-way bills, and the reconciliation are the answer. A speech about the business is not.
Appeal, and what this page will not describe
An adjudication order can be appealed to the appellate authority within the time the Act allows, and further as the statute provides. A pre-deposit is part of some of those appeals. Missing the period is not repaired by a long grievance letter. This page does not describe a way to suppress turnover, to issue invoices for supplies that were not made, or to claim credit that the invoices do not support. Those acts are the facts a section 74 notice is written about.
Questions people ask
Should the tax be paid the day the notice arrives?
The notice states a proposal. Payment before an order has consequences the section itself sets out. It is not always the same as losing the right to answer.
Is a portal upload enough if the hearing was not given?
The record of what was filed, and of whether a hearing was fixed, is what an appeal looks at.
Does a notice freeze the business?
A notice is not, by itself, a cancellation of registration. Cancellation is a separate proceeding.
Related notes
These pages are further general information. They are not a referral and they are not an invitation to engage the firm.
The Bar Council of India does not permit advertisement or solicitation by advocates in any form or manner. By reading this page you acknowledge that you are seeking general information of your own accord and that there has been no solicitation, advertisement, or inducement. This page is not legal advice and it is not a claim of specialisation under Rule 36 of the Bar Council of India Rules, framed under the Advocates Act, 1961. It does not create an advocate-client relationship. Consistent with Rule 37 of those Rules, nothing here permits a person who is not an advocate to practise law, or to draft, file, or appear in any proceeding. Lawfy & Co. is not liable for any action taken solely in reliance on this general information. Office addresses and telephone numbers are published on the contact page as directory information.

