Lawfy & Co

Medical treatment and legal proceedings

A factual note on when treatment is discussed before a consumer commission, a civil court, or, rarely, a criminal court. It does not state a figure for compensation.

Three different proceedings

A paid medical service can be a service under the consumer law. The Supreme Court held that in Indian Medical Association v. V.P. Shantha. A complaint about deficiency in that service is one route. A civil suit for damages is another. A criminal case is a third, and it is not the ordinary consequence of a bad outcome. In Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab the Supreme Court held that criminal negligence by a doctor requires a high degree of negligence, not a mere error of judgment. An injury, or a death, does not by itself answer that test.

The forum under the Consumer Protection Act depends on the consideration paid and on the pecuniary jurisdiction in force when the complaint is filed. A complaint that is really about a diagnosis everyone regrets, with no failure of the duty of care, is a weak complaint. The case sheet, the consent, the investigations, and the discharge summary are the record. A relative’s account is part of the facts. It is not a substitute for that record.

What should not be done with the papers

Guidelines in cases such as Kusum Sharma ask for proper particulars and, often, for a medical opinion before a negligence case is allowed to proceed as if the conclusion were obvious. Inventing a symptom, altering a consent form, or demanding a sum with no relation to the treatment is not a way to make a file stronger. This page does not set out a figure, and it does not set out a way to write a record that was not made at the time.

Questions people ask

Is every complication negligence?

No. Medicine has risks that are not a breach of duty.

Is a criminal case the fastest route to money?

No. Criminal negligence is exceptional, and a criminal court is not a compensation forum of first resort.

Whose papers are needed?

The hospital record, the bills, and the consent. Later opinions should say what they read.

Related notes

These pages are further general information. They are not a referral and they are not an invitation to engage the firm.

The Bar Council of India does not permit advertisement or solicitation by advocates in any form or manner. By reading this page you acknowledge that you are seeking general information of your own accord and that there has been no solicitation, advertisement, or inducement. This page is not legal advice and it is not a claim of specialisation under Rule 36 of the Bar Council of India Rules, framed under the Advocates Act, 1961. It does not create an advocate-client relationship. Consistent with Rule 37 of those Rules, nothing here permits a person who is not an advocate to practise law, or to draft, file, or appear in any proceeding. Lawfy & Co. is not liable for any action taken solely in reliance on this general information. Office addresses and telephone numbers are published on the contact page as directory information.