Legal Insights

Criminal Appeal and Revision Petition in the High Court (Surat)

A criminal revision petition asks a higher court to check the legality, correctness and propriety of a lower criminal order, and it is not a second appeal on facts.

2026-11-13 9 min read
Blogs
Criminal Appeal and Revision Petition in the High Court (Surat)

Last reviewed: November 2026

An appeal and a revision are different applications. An appeal challenges a conviction on the terms the code gives. A revision asks whether the order is legal, correct and proper. Treating one as the other can close the door that was actually open.

This page is general information. It promises no outcome. From 1 July 2024 the new procedure code is in force, with savings for proceedings already pending. An enrolled advocate should settle the filing before it is submitted.

Key Insights

01A criminal revision petition is not a rehearing of the evidence. The court looks for illegality, a material irregularity, or a finding that cannot stand. It does not weigh the witnesses again as if it were the trial court.
02An appeal from conviction under Section 374 CrPC goes to the Court of Session when a Magistrate passed the sentence, and to the High Court when a Court of Session passed it. The forum follows the court that convicted, not the city where the accused lives.
03The route called a criminal appeal in high court is the challenge to a conviction by a Court of Session, or to an order the statute places before the High Court. It is a full appeal on the terms the code allows, which is wider than revision.
04The limitation for criminal appeal depends on the court and the sentence. For a sentence other than death, the period to the High Court is sixty days, and the period to any other court is thirty days, counted as the Limitation Act provides.
05A late filing is not cured by a long grounds paragraph. The court needs an application showing sufficient cause. Until that application is allowed, the challenge is not in time.

The conviction was pronounced last month and the lawyer's clerk has both an appeal form and a revision form on the desk. Which one matches the court that passed the sentence?

Speak to the Lawfy & Co. Surat team about your matter.

When a criminal revision petition lies

The court hearing a criminal revision petition calls for the record of the court below. Section 438 BNSS is the provision in the new code under which that call is made, corresponding to the old power to examine correctness, legality and propriety. Section 438 BNSS is not a power to take fresh evidence as a routine, and it is not a power to replace a finding merely because another view of the witnesses was possible.

An interlocutory order is generally outside a criminal revision petition. The order, not the label on the form, decides that. Where an appeal lay and was not filed, a criminal revision petition is often barred.

The High Court and the Court of Session can each be the forum for a criminal revision petition, according to which court passed the order. The code restricts a routine second revision. Filing a criminal revision petition does not by itself suspend the order under challenge.

Papers for a criminal revision petition include a certified copy of the order, the grounds, the record the court will call for, and a delay application if the filing is outside the period. The period commonly applied to revision is 90 days from the order. That figure is the revision period. It is not the appeal period. A second reminder of the same rule: revision is brought within 90 days, subject to exclusion of time spent obtaining a copy and to any order condoning delay.

QuestionAppeal against convictionRevision
What it challengesThe conviction and sentence, on the statutory appealLegality, correctness or propriety of the order
Old textSection 374 CrPCThe power to call for the record
New textSection 415 BNSS, for appeals from convictionsSection 438 BNSS, for calling the record
Usual periodSixty days to the High Court, thirty days to another courtThe revision article, not the appeal article
Effect on the sentenceA separate prayer can seek suspensionFiling a criminal revision petition does not stay the order

Appeal from a conviction, and which court

Section 374 CrPC is the appeal from conviction in the old code. Section 415 BNSS is the appeals-from-convictions provision in the code in force from 1 July 2024, and it corresponds to that older section. A conviction by a Magistrate is appealed to the Court of Session. A conviction by a Court of Session, or by an Additional Sessions Judge, is the criminal appeal in high court. The High Court of Gujarat hears that appeal from a sessions conviction in this State.

The code also names other High Court challenges, including some by the State against sentence. Those are not the accused's appeal against conviction. Name the convicting court in the cause title.

The limitation for criminal appeal to the High Court, where the sentence is not a death sentence, is sixty days from the date of the sentence or order. The period to the Court of Session is thirty days. Time spent obtaining a copy is excluded as the Limitation Act provides. Keep the copy application and the date the copy was ready.

An acquittal appeal is a different proceeding. The State may appeal against an acquittal on the terms the code sets. In a case started on a private complaint, the complainant generally needs leave before an acquittal appeal can go forward. That leave is not a formality to be assumed. A person who was acquitted should read any notice of that appeal carefully, and should not treat it as a revision filed by the other side under a wrong name.

A criminal appeal in high court is argued on the record. The appellate court can reappreciate evidence within the limits of an appeal. That is wider than revision. New documents never put to the witnesses are not, by themselves, a ground.

Time, delay and the papers to file

The limitation for criminal appeal is computed from the sentence or order, not from the day a relative understood the result. If an application for a copy was made, keep the receipt. If no copy was applied for, do not invent an application date. The court sees the endorsement on the copy.

A filing after the period needs condonation of delay. The application has to show sufficient cause for each stretch of time. Distress alone, with no dates, is a weak reason. A hospital record, or a copy delay the Limitation Act does not already exclude, is the sort of fact the court can weigh.

The same discipline applies to revision. Do not write sixty days on a revision and thirty days on a sessions appeal because the forms look similar. The limitation for criminal appeal and the revision period are different articles of the Limitation Act. Mixing them is how a filing is returned, or is heard first on delay instead of on the order.

Section 374 CrPC filings that are in fact governed by the new code should cite Section 415 BNSS, and the reverse. A pending matter that began before 1 July 2024 often continues under the old code. Check the order, not the year on an old form.

Sentence held back while the challenge is pending

Suspension of sentence is the appellate court's power to hold the sentence in abeyance and, where proper, to release the appellant on bail while the appeal is pending. It is not an acquittal and not a forecast. Custody already undergone, and a short sentence, are facts. They are not a formula.

That suspension of sentence should be asked for in the appeal, with the conviction and the custody position clearly stated. A criminal revision petition is the wrong vehicle if what the person needed was an appeal and a prayer to hold the sentence. Filing the wrong vehicle, and then asking the court to treat it as the right one, costs time the limitation clock may not return.

How a file from this city usually moves

A conviction by a Magistrate in this city is appealed to the Court of Session. A conviction by the Court of Session is the criminal appeal in high court, heard by the High Court of Gujarat. The court complex at Athwalines lists much of the city's criminal work. The board names the court. Counters move, so check the registry.

Choosing revision because the appeal period was missed does not rename the appeal. If any remedy remains, it is to face the delay in the appeal that actually lies.

A reader in this city who is considering a criminal revision petition should first ask whether an appeal was available and was not used.

Need help with a matter of this kind in Surat?

Our Surat office can look at the papers you already have.

Lawfy & Co. Surat Office

Speak to Our Surat Team

If you need guidance on the subject of this note, call or WhatsApp the Lawfy & Co. Surat office. Share the basic facts and the documents you have, and the team will explain the possible next steps.

Contacting the office does not by itself create an advocate-client relationship.

7 Hiral Arcade, 3rd Floor, Opposite New Court, Meghdoot Society, Athwalines, Athwa, Surat, Gujarat 395007

Phone: +91 91471 09222

Email: ask@lawfyco.in

WhatsApp: +91 91471 09222

Frequently Asked Questions

Which court hears an appeal from a Magistrate's conviction?

The Court of Session. Section 374 CrPC sent that appeal to the Sessions Court, and the new code keeps the same structure for appeals from convictions. The High Court is not the first appellate court for an ordinary Magistrate's sentence.

When does the High Court hear the accused's appeal?

When the conviction is by a Court of Session, the challenge is a criminal appeal in high court. Other High Court appeals exist, including some by the State, and they should not be copied onto an accused's form by habit.

What if the filing is late?

File the challenge that actually lies, with an application for condonation of delay that explains each period. The limitation for criminal appeal is not extended by calling the paper a revision. Sufficient cause is decided on the reasons, not on the length of the grounds.

Does filing a revision stop the sentence?

No. A criminal revision petition does not by itself suspend the sentence or the order. Suspension is a separate prayer, usually in the appeal. Ask for the order that is actually needed, in the proceeding that is actually open.

हिंदी सवाल-जवाब

सजा के खिलाफ अपील कहाँ होगी?

मजिस्ट्रेट की सजा के खिलाफ अपील सेशन अदालत में होती है। सेशन अदालत की सजा के खिलाफ अपील हाई कोर्ट में होती है। किस अदालत ने सजा दी, वही फोरम तय करता है। रहने का शहर फोरम नहीं बदलता।

रिवीजन और अपील में क्या फर्क है?

अपील कानून का अधिकार है और सबूत पर जा सकती है। रिवीजन में ऊपरी अदालत यह देखती है कि आदेश कानूनी, सही और उचित है या नहीं। जहाँ अपील बनती हो और न की गई हो, रिवीजन अक्सर बंद होता है।

देर से दाखिल करने पर क्या करना होगा?

देरी का कारण तारीखों के साथ लिखना होता है। केवल यह लिखना कि परिवार परेशान था, अक्सर काफी नहीं होता। प्रतिलिपि मंगाने का समय कानून के अनुसार अलग गिना जाता है। उसकी रसीद फाइल में रखें।

The information in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is formed by reading this content.