Last reviewed: November 2026
Rules 36 and 37 of the Bar Council of India Rules restrict solicitation and advertising. This page is general information about the statute and the way a petition is tried. It is not a view on any one marriage, and it promises no decree. Conduct before the marriage is background. The ground is conduct after the solemnization.
Key Insights
Table of Contents
A spouse has a set of incidents, and also a criminal file, and wants to know which facts belong in the divorce petition. What should the pleading actually contain?
Speak to the Lawfy & Co. Surat team about your matter.
The cruelty ground for divorce
Reading the cruelty ground for divorce as a test of one quarrel is a mistake. The Act allows a decree where, after the solemnization, the respondent has treated the petitioner with cruelty. The court looks at the conduct as a whole. A grave single act can be enough. So can a series of smaller acts. Ordinary friction is not the test, and neither spouse's private slogan is the test.
The cruelty ground for divorce can be made out by either spouse. The Act is not written for one gender. In practice many petitions narrate the husband's conduct, because that is the life the wife says she was made to live. The legal test does not change with the cause title. What changes is the proof: who did what, on which date, and who saw or heard it.
V. Bhagat v. D. Bhagat (1994) describes mental cruelty as conduct so painful that the other spouse cannot reasonably be asked to put up with it. Samar Ghosh v. Jaya Ghosh (2007) refused to turn that idea into a frozen checklist. The court asks whether this marriage can reasonably continue after this conduct. The clause it is applying is Section 13(1)(ia).
N.G. Dastane v. S. Dastane (1975) fixed a civil standard of proof, the balance of probabilities, not proof beyond reasonable doubt. Vague charges still fail. The respondent is entitled to know the incidents and to test them in cross-examination.
Physical cruelty and mental cruelty
Physical cruelty still needs a date, a place, the injury, and who saw it that day. A medico-legal paper is stronger than a recollection given years later. Delay is not fatal by itself. Silence at the time, with no explanation, is a fact the respondent will use.
Mental cruelty by husband is assessed from what he did, not from a label in the cause title. The court wants the pattern. Cutting a wife off from her parents, ridiculing her in front of relatives, demanding that she leave her work, refusing her food or medicine, threatening to throw her out, or carrying on a relationship and flaunting it, are the kinds of facts that get pleaded. Each one still needs a time and a witness or a document. A mood, described without an incident, is not a pleading.
Sustained humiliation is the usual core of a plea of mental cruelty by husband even when no injury report exists. A single slap may separately be physical cruelty. The two can sit in one petition if both happened. They should not be blended into one sentence. The written statement has to be able to admit, deny, or explain each head. A blended sentence can be denied in one word.
Mental cruelty by husband is not proved by friends repeating it. Messages, a contemporary diary, and people who were in the room are the useful material. Do not create messages after the split. A fabricated incident, once exposed, damages the rest of the petition.
The wife who pleads mental cruelty by husband should annex dated messages, any medical papers, and a one-page chronology. Name a relative only for a specific act. Say what the husband did, and say it separately.
A case of mental cruelty by husband can include deliberate neglect: withholding support while having the means, or using exclusion as punishment. Illness, unemployment, or a short separation both sides treated as temporary is a different fact.
People ask for a mental cruelty divorce when there is no agreement on consent terms and the marriage has become unbearable on one side. A mental cruelty divorce is not a separate Act and not a counsellor's certificate. It is a decree under the cruelty clause, or it is a dismissal. The phrase describes the facts. The statute supplies the ground.
The time a mental cruelty divorce takes follows the incidents and the witnesses, not a fixed calendar. A short, dated petition finishes sooner than ten years of undated quarrels. Settlement of a mental cruelty divorce is recorded only when the court sees that both spouses understand the terms.
Pleadings, the reply and condonation
The petition opens with the marriage and the children, then the conduct in date order. If the day is unknown, say so. Interim support, an injunction, or a child's arrangement is a separate paper. Conduct that continues after filing belongs in an amendment the court permits, not in a surprise affidavit.
A written statement that answers the cruelty ground for divorce date by date is more useful than a general denial. The incident never happened, the words were different, the petitioner was the aggressor, or the spouses resumed life afterwards: those are different defences. Plead the one that is true.
Section 23 bars relief where the petitioner takes advantage of his or her own wrong, or has condoned the cruelty. Condonation is a return to marital life with knowledge of the conduct and an intention to forgive it. A meeting about a child is not automatically condonation. Months of resumed married life come much closer. Fresh conduct can revive what was condoned. Plead that revival if it happened.
A divorce petition is not ordinarily presented in the first year of the marriage, unless the case is one of exceptional hardship or exceptional depravity. State the facts. Adjectives are not leave. A later petition faces delay, memory and condonation instead.
A counter-petition is available where the respondent also wants a divorce, on cruelty or on another statutory ground. It is tried with the main petition unless the court directs otherwise. Each spouse then carries a burden on his or her own pleading. A counter-petition is not proved by showing that the other side's story is weak.
How the family court tries the petition
Where a family court exists, it is the ordinary forum. Jurisdiction follows the Act: the place of marriage, the respondent's residence, the last joint home, or, if the wife petitions, the place she lives. A failed settlement meeting is not a finding. It records that the parties did not agree.
Interim support under Section 24, and litigation expenses, can be asked for while the petition is pending. The court looks at income, needs, and the standard the couple actually had. That order keeps a spouse able to prosecute or defend the case. It is not a finding on the cruelty ground for divorce. Do not read a monthly figure as a signal of who will win. Non-payment can be executed. It does not, by itself, prove the incidents.
Affidavits often stand as the examination-in-chief. Cross-examination tests that evidence. A paper produced for the first time in the box, which was never disclosed, is often kept out of the evidence the court will read. Paginate the set before the first affidavit is sworn. Put the marriage proof, the medical papers, the messages and the chronology in one index. A witness who was present should say what he or she perceived, not what the petitioner later explained. Opinion about who is a good spouse is not useful.
Answer the question the judge asked. After both sides close, there are arguments and a judgment on the incidents that were pleaded, not on a new theory. A decree dissolves the marriage. It does not, by itself, divide property or fix a child's residence.
Appeal lies against a decree on the cruelty ground for divorce, on the record and within limitation. A later incident is not added as if it had been tried. An agreement reached in the appeal can still be placed before that court.
A mental cruelty divorce decree does not decide a criminal case on the same facts. The standards, the parties and the forums differ. An acquittal does not automatically dismiss the petition, and a decree does not automatically convict. Each file is argued on its own material. Tell each court that the other file exists, so that a fact is not stated one way in one building and another way in the next.
Criminal cases arising from the same home
K. Srinivas Rao v. D.A. Deepa (2013) treats unfounded criminal proceedings, and indecent allegations that fail, as capable of amounting to cruelty. A spouse who was assaulted may still inform the police. False complaints, launched without a factual base, are a different act. The court reads the outcome and the way the case was pursued.
The respondent who faces false complaints should bring the closure report, the acquittal, or the withdrawal. A pending case is not yet proof that the complaint was false. Do not ask the family court to try the criminal charge. Filing a mental cruelty divorce does not stay that criminal case unless a court orders a stay.
If the criminal allegations and the petition clash on dates, fix one chronology before either affidavit is sworn. Specific acts survive. A list of every relative, with no act, does not. That clash is not cured by calling the file mental cruelty by husband.
Leaving after a beating, or asking for protection, is not cruelty. A complaint that tracks real incidents is lawful. A complaint built only to force money is something else, and the messages usually show which one it was. The second kind is not proved by repeating the phrase mental cruelty by husband.
Breakdown of the marriage and the limits of the trial court
Time apart can be the result of cruelty, or it can be desertion. Desertion needs its own facts: the statutory period, the intention to end cohabitation, and the absence of consent or reasonable cause. Do not treat years apart as cruelty without the conduct.
Irretrievable breakdown is not a ground the family court can use to dissolve a Hindu marriage. Spouses, and sometimes judges, describe a marriage as finished because the parties have lived apart for years and there is no affection left. That description may be true. It is not, by itself, Section 13. The trial court still needs a statutory ground, proved on the record.
In Shilpa Sailesh v. Varun Sreenivasan (2023) the Supreme Court held that it may dissolve a marriage on irretrievable breakdown under Article 142, even if one spouse does not consent, after looking at separation, settlement attempts, money, children, and whether the marriage is beyond repair. That power is not the family court's. A family court has no Article 142 power.
A consent petition is a different proceeding. Do not dress it up as cruelty if there is no cruelty to prove. If consent fails, the fought petition continues on the incidents that are true. A figure that cannot be paid is not a settlement.
A contested petition in the city
Surat has a family court. File where the Act places jurisdiction, often the last joint home or, if the wife petitions, where she lives. A wrong court is a year lost. Carry the marriage proof, the indexed incidents, and any criminal orders. Check the board before the date. A video statement is for the judge to allow, not to assume. Miss a date only with an application. Ask for an outstation witness by video before the week of the trial.
A mental cruelty divorce in this court is won or lost on the incidents, the reply and the cross-examination. Correct a wrong date before the affidavit, not after the other side has built questions on it.
In Surat the family court tries the petition on the record the parties actually file. A decree on the cruelty ground for divorce is only as strong as the dates, the documents and the answers given in cross-examination.
Need help with a matter of this kind in Surat?
Our Surat office can look at the papers you already have.
Lawfy & Co. Surat Office
Speak to Our Surat Team
If you need guidance on the subject of this note, call or WhatsApp the Lawfy & Co. Surat office. Share the basic facts and the documents you have, and the team will explain the possible next steps.
Contacting the office does not by itself create an advocate-client relationship.
7 Hiral Arcade, 3rd Floor, Opposite New Court, Meghdoot Society, Athwalines, Athwa, Surat, Gujarat 395007
Phone: +91 91471 09222
Email: ask@lawfyco.in
WhatsApp: +91 91471 09222
Frequently Asked Questions
What does the court look for on this ground?
The cruelty ground for divorce is a finding that, after the marriage, the respondent's conduct made it unreasonable to continue living together. The court wants dates, words, documents and witnesses. It does not want a character sketch. Physical injury and a long pattern of humiliation are both capable of meeting the test. Ordinary marital friction is not.
Is there a fixed list of acts that count as mental cruelty?
No. Samar Ghosh v. Jaya Ghosh (2007) refused a closed list. The court looks at the cumulative conduct, the social setting of that marriage, and whether cohabitation has become unreasonable. Grave isolated acts can qualify. The wear and tear of ordinary married life does not. A pleading should describe the acts and stop there.
Does a failed criminal case decide the divorce?
Not by itself. False complaints that were serious, indecent and without foundation can be used as cruelty, which is the point drawn from K. Srinivas Rao v. D.A. Deepa (2013). A prosecution that is still pending is not yet a finding that the complaint was false. An acquittal is read with its reasons. The divorce is still decided on the civil standard.
Can the family court divorce the couple only because they have lived apart?
No. Irretrievable breakdown is not one of its grounds, and it has no power of the kind exercised under Article 142. Long separation may support desertion, or it may show the effect of cruelty, but only if those facts are pleaded and proved. A consent petition is a different route, and both spouses have to stay with it.
हिंदी सवाल-जवाब
क्रूरता की याचिका में कौन से तथ्य लिखने जरूरी हैं?
विवाह की तारीख और उसके बाद की घटनाएँ, तारीख, जगह, शब्द और गवाह के साथ। केवल "वह क्रूर था" पर्याप्त नहीं। शारीरिक चोट और लंबे अपमान अलग-अलग पैरा में रखें। झूठी घटना जोड़ने से पूरी याचिका कमजोर होती है।
आपराधिक मुकदमा और तलाक का मुकदमा एक ही फैसला है क्या?
नहीं। दोनों का मानक, पक्ष और मंच अलग हैं। बरी होना अपने आप तलाक खारिज नहीं करता, और तलाक की डिक्री अपने आप सजा नहीं है। दोनों अदालतों को दूसरे मामले की जानकारी दें।
क्या लंबे अलगाव मात्र से फैमिली कोर्ट तलाक दे देती है?
नहीं। अलगाव अपने आप क्रूरता नहीं है। परित्याग अलग आधार है और उसके अपने तथ्य चाहिए। शहर की अदालत के पास सर्वोच्च अदालत वाली विशेष शक्ति नहीं है। आपसी सहमति अलग कार्यवाही है।
The information in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is formed by reading this content.

