Legal Insights

Rights of an Arrested Person and the D K Basu Guidelines (Kolkata)

The d k basu guidelines are the binding directions on how an arrest is recorded, whom the police must tell, and how the person is produced in court. This note sets out the rights of arrested person in that framework, including arrest without warrant, as they are applied in Kolkata and elsewhere.

2026-11-13 11 min read
Blogs
Rights of an Arrested Person and the D K Basu Guidelines (Kolkata)

Last reviewed: November 2026

An arrest is a loss of liberty before any finding of guilt. The Constitution and the procedure code both treat it as exceptional, even when it is lawful. The judgment that put the daily routine of arrest into a list of duties is D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal, decided by the Supreme Court in 1996 and reported in 1997. The list is what stations are supposed to follow on the day itself, not only what a court recites years later.

What follows explains those duties, the constitutional clock, and the difference between an arrest the officer may make and an arrest the officer must justify. It does not describe how to avoid a lawful arrest, and it does not advise anyone to resist one.

Key Insights

01The d k basu guidelines require identification of the arresting officers, a written memo at the time of arrest, information to a relative or friend, a medical check, and information to the Magistrate. They are not courtesies. Breach can be taken up in court.
02Article 22 gives two protections that operate at once: the person must be told the grounds of arrest and must be allowed to consult a lawyer, and must be produced before a Magistrate within 24 hours, excluding the time of the journey. A longer detention without that production is illegal.
03The rights of arrested person include being told that a relative can be informed, meeting a lawyer during interrogation though not necessarily throughout it, and a medical examination at reasonable intervals while in custody. These sit alongside the older constitutional guarantees.
04Custody without a warrant is lawful only in the cases the procedure code lists, chiefly cognizable offences, and only when the officer records why custody is needed. Joginder Kumar v. State of Uttar Pradesh (1994) held that the power to arrest is not a duty to arrest in every case.
05For offences punishable with imprisonment up to seven years, Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar (2014) and the successor provision in the new procedure code require a notice to appear instead of automatic arrest, unless reasons for arrest are recorded. A graver offence is outside that seven-year line. Custody is still not casual.

A shopkeeper in Kolkata was taken from the shop in the evening and the family was not told which station held him. Which paper should exist from the moment of arrest?

Speak to the Lawfy & Co. Kolkata team about your matter.

What the d k basu guidelines require

The d k basu guidelines were issued because arrests were being made without a record that could later be checked. Officers should wear visible identification. A memo of arrest is prepared at the time, attested by a relative or a respectable local person, and countersigned by the person arrested, with the time and date.

A friend or relative is told of the arrest and the place of custody. The person is informed of that right at once. A diary entry names who was told and which officers have custody. Injuries are recorded if the person asks, and a medical examination by a doctor is repeated at intervals of about forty-eight hours. Copies go to the Magistrate. A lawyer may be met during interrogation, though not throughout. A control room should display the arrest and the place of custody.

Production without the papers is not compliance. A missing memo is a fact on bail, not a clerical detail.

DutyWhenWhat the paper shows
Visible identificationAt arrest and interrogationName and designation of the officers
Memo, attested and countersignedAt the time of arrestTime, date, and a witness to the arrest
News to a relative or friendAs soon as the arrest is madeWho was told, and the place of custody
Inspection of injuriesAt arrest, if sought, and later at intervalsWhat was found, signed by both sides
Copy to the MagistrateWith productionThat the court received the arrest papers
Access to a lawyerDuring interrogation, not necessarily throughoutThat legal advice was not shut out

The constitutional clock and the lawyer

Article 22 of the Constitution is the text behind the clock. The person is informed of the grounds of arrest and is entitled to consult and to be defended by a legal practitioner of their choice. The right to lawyer is not a favour granted if the investigation is convenient. It is a constitutional entitlement. Advice can be restricted in the sense that the lawyer need not sit through every question. It cannot be refused altogether.

Production before the nearest Magistrate is due within 24 hours, excluding the time necessary for the journey from the place of arrest to the court. The same limit is in the procedure code. A remand, if custody is to continue, is an order of that Magistrate, for reasons, not a police decision to "keep him one more night". Judicial custody and police custody are different orders. Police custody is the rarer and the more closely controlled of the two.

The rights of arrested person at this stage are concrete. Grounds, in a language the person understands. A lawyer. A relative told. A court within the clock. None of these is satisfied by a verbal assurance at the station gate. If the family learns of the arrest only when a neighbour calls, the information duty has not been performed, whatever the FIR later says.

An enemy alien and a preventive-detention order follow different constitutional clauses. An ordinary criminal arrest is the case this note describes. Mixing preventive detention with a penal arrest produces the wrong clock and the wrong court.

When police may arrest without warrant

Arrest without warrant is governed by the provision that replaced Section 41 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, now Section 35 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. A police officer may arrest, without an order from a Magistrate and without a warrant, in the classes of cases that section lists. The important class is a cognizable offence, and even there the officer is to be satisfied that the arrest is necessary for one of the stated reasons: to prevent further offence, for proper investigation, to prevent tampering, to prevent disappearance, or to ensure presence. The reasons are recorded. A printed line that says "arrest was necessary" is weaker than reasons that refer to the facts of that person.

That route is not the course for a non-cognizable case. There the officer's path is information to the Magistrate, unless a separate power applies. Complaints that begin as non-cognizable are sometimes rewritten with a cognizable section so that an arrest can be made. If the cognizable section is unsupported, the arrest is open to challenge. The remedy is a court, not a scuffle at the station.

For offences punishable with up to seven years, the notice to appear, the successor of Section 41A, is the default. Arrest follows only if the person does not comply or if recorded reasons justify arrest. Arnesh Kumar is the authority for the discipline.

The rights of arrested person do not depend on whether the arrest was with a warrant or without one. A warranted arrest still needs the memo, the relative, the doctor and the Magistrate. A warrantless arrest adds the question whether the statute allowed the officer to act without that warrant at all. Both questions can be live in the same file.

Memo, relative, doctor, diary

The arrest memo is the single page that later proves when and where the person was taken. It should carry the offence alleged, the place, the time, the names of the officers, and the signature or thumb impression of the person arrested, with an independent attestation. A memo written the next afternoon, after a night in the lock-up, does not become timely because it is eventually signed. The d k basu guidelines fix the time as the time of arrest.

To inform relative is a separate act from handing the person a phone for thirty seconds. The relative's name, the relationship, and the place of custody should be capable of being shown to the Magistrate. If the person names no one, the station records that, and uses the legal-aid route the judgment describes. "He refused to name anyone" is a fact that itself has to be recorded, not a sentence added after a complaint.

A medical examination is recorded and placed with the production. The right to lawyer is not postponed until a statement has been signed.

If the duties are skipped

A skipped duty does not, by itself, end the prosecution. It is a fact on bail, on the legality of the remand, and sometimes on a separate proceeding for compensation or for departmental action. The Supreme Court in D.K. Basu also spoke of compensation for custodial violence as a public-law remedy. That remedy is for proved harm. It is not an automatic payment because a form was late. The criminal case, if the accusation is otherwise real, continues, and the illegality of the arrest is dealt with on its own terms.

The remedy for a bad arrest is the Magistrate on the first production, and the High Court where the detention is illegal.

Arrest paperwork in Kolkata

The first production in the city is before the Magistrate having jurisdiction. Bankshall and the other metropolitan courts divide that work. The station named in the FIR is the starting point.

The Calcutta High Court hears habeas corpus and bail after the Magistrate or the Court of Session. The roster decides the bench.

The d k basu guidelines do not have a separate Kolkata text. The rights of arrested person on that first morning are the memo, the relative's name and the time of production. What changes is which Magistrate takes the production. The notice or the FIR names the station. That name is what the family writes down.

Need help with a matter of this kind in Kolkata?

Our Kolkata office can look at the papers you already have.

Lawfy & Co. Kolkata Office

Speak to Our Kolkata Team

If you need guidance on the subject of this note, call or WhatsApp the Lawfy & Co. Kolkata office. Share the basic facts and the documents you have, and the team will explain the possible next steps.

Contacting the office does not by itself create an advocate-client relationship.

4ES8 Mani Casadona, Newtown, Street No. 372, Action Area II, Kolkata, West Bengal 700156

Phone: +91 91471 09222

Email: ask@lawfyco.in

WhatsApp: +91 91471 09222

Frequently Asked Questions

What must be prepared at the moment of arrest?

A memo, with the time and date, attested by a witness and signed by the person arrested, and information to a relative or friend about the arrest and the place. The arrest memo is not optional. Officers should be identifiable by name and designation. Copies reach the Magistrate with the production.

How soon must the person see a Magistrate?

Within 24 hours, not counting the journey. That limit is in Article 22 and in the procedure code. A remand, if custody continues, is the Magistrate's order. The police do not extend the clock by their own note.

Does every cognizable case require an arrest?

No. Arrest without warrant is a power, and for offences up to seven years it is restrained by the notice-to-appear rule. The officer records why custody is necessary. Joginder Kumar and Arnesh Kumar are the authorities for that restraint. A graver offence is still not an arrest without reasons.

Can the family be refused the name of the station?

No. The duty to inform relative exists so that the family knows the place of custody. A control-room display is part of the same scheme. Refusal is a breach. It is raised before the Magistrate and, where the person cannot be traced, in a habeas corpus petition.

हिंदी सवाल-जवाब

गिरफ्तारी के समय कौन सा कागज बनना चाहिए?

गिरफ्तारी का मेमो, समय और तारीख के साथ, गवाह के हस्ताक्षर और गिरफ्तार व्यक्ति के हस्ताक्षर सहित। किसी रिश्तेदार या मित्र को जगह बताई जानी चाहिए। यह कागज मजिस्ट्रेट के पास भी जाता है।

व्यक्ति को अदालत के सामने कितनी देर में लाया जाए?

चौबीस घंटे के भीतर, रास्ते का समय छोड़कर। आगे की हिरासत मजिस्ट्रेट के आदेश से होती है। पुलिस अपने नोट से यह समय नहीं बढ़ा सकती।

क्या हर संज्ञेय मामले में गिरफ्तारी जरूरी है?

नहीं। बिना वारंट गिरफ्तारी एक शक्ति है, हर मामले का कर्तव्य नहीं। सात साल तक की सजा वाले अपराधों में पहले पेश होने का नोटिस है। कारण लिखे बिना हिरासत नहीं होनी चाहिए।

The information in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is formed by reading this content.