Last reviewed: November 2026
An FIR that uses the words "attempt to murder" has chosen one of the grave sections in the penal code. The words are not a description of how badly someone was hurt. They are a legal conclusion about the doer's mind, read with the surrounding facts. A deep wound can fall short of the section. A wound that a doctor calls simple can still meet it, if the other facts show the required mind.
What follows is about that test, the sentence the statute allows, bail, and the narrow space for a settlement. It does not describe how violence is carried out. It is not a police-statement script.
Key Insights
Table of Contents
A family in Kolkata has an FIR after a neighbourhood fight in which one person was taken to hospital. Which document should be read before anyone says the charge must fail because the person survived?
Speak to the Lawfy & Co. Kolkata team about your matter.
What section 307 ipc requires
Section 307 ipc is built on the definition of murder. The prosecution has to show an act, a mental element of the kind that would make the killing murder if death followed, and circumstances that fit that conclusion. In Om Prakash v. State of Punjab (1961) the Supreme Court held that the act need not be the last act possible. Starving a person, or a series of acts, can be enough if the mind and the circumstances are proved. Survival does not erase the charge.
Section 109 bns restates the offence for the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. The core test is the same. An act before 1 July 2024 is still section 307 ipc. An act on or after that date is charged under the new provision. Citing both, without tying each to a date, is a defect in the draft. It is not a second offence.
Under section 307 ipc, knowledge is the alternative to the purposive mind. The accused must have known that the act was so imminently dangerous that it must in all probability cause death, or such bodily injury as is likely to cause death, and committed the act without excuse. That is the murder standard, carried into the attempt. A push in a quarrel, with no weapon and no aim at a vital part, is usually hurt or grievous hurt, not section 307 ipc. The prosecution does not get the section by using a serious adjective.
The charge under section 307 ipc is cognizable and non-bailable, and it is tried by a Court of Session. The offence is non-compoundable under the statutory table. Those three labels decide the police power of arrest, the bail forum, and the fact that a private receipt is not an acquittal. They do not decide guilt.
Hurt, the weapon, and the doctor's note
The injury report is the document that records the nature of the hurt, the weapon as the doctor infers it, and whether the hurt is simple or grievous. It is one piece of the file. In State of Maharashtra v. Balram Bama Patil (1983) the Supreme Court held that a conviction can stand even where the injuries are simple, if the mental element is otherwise proved. An injury report that describes simple hurt does not, by itself, rule the charge in or out.
State of Madhya Pradesh v. Saleem (2005) tells the court to look at the weapon, the part of the body, and the force. A single blow with a lathi on a non-vital part, in a sudden fight, has often been held to fall short. Repeated blows, a sharp weapon, and a stated aim at the head or the chest are facts from which the court may draw the mental element. None of these facts is a formula. The judgment is on the evidence in that file, including what the witnesses actually say they saw.
The doctor's opinion that an injury was "sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death" is relevant and is not conclusive. The opinion is read with the seat of the injury and with whether death was averted by prompt treatment. Prompt treatment that saves a life does not downgrade section 307 ipc as a rule of law. Equally, a grave medical opinion does not relieve the prosecution of proving the mental element.
Grievous hurt, and attempt to commit culpable homicide not amounting to murder, sit nearby. They carry their own sections and their own maxima. A court at the charge stage can frame a lesser charge if the material, taken at its highest, does not reach murder's mental element. That choice is the judge's, on the record, not a word the accused is entitled to dictate.
Sentence under the old text and the new text
Where no hurt is caused, the maximum under section 307 ipc is ten years, and a fine. Where hurt is caused, the court may impose imprisonment for life, or that lesser punishment. A person already undergoing imprisonment for life, who causes hurt while offending in this way, faces a still heavier sentence, which can extend to death. Those are the limbs of the section. They are also why a bail note must say whether hurt is alleged at all.
The ten years limb is the lesser maximum. It is easy to mis-cite. A draft that tells the court the maximum is always life, in a case where no hurt is alleged, overstates the statute. A draft that tells the court the maximum is only 10 years, where the FIR alleges hurt, understates it. Section 109 bns follows the same split for later acts. The aggravated life-convict limb should be cited only when the custody status matches it.
Fines are additional, not a substitute, where the section says the offender shall also be liable to fine. The criminal court is not calculating compensation as if it were a civil decree, though a compensation power exists separately and is used, when it is used, on the statutory terms. A family settlement about hospital bills does not amend the maximum.
Bail, custody and conditions
Because section 307 ipc is non-bailable, bail is a judicial decision. The Magistrate's power is limited once the punishment can extend to life. In practice, bail before committal is moved in the sessions court, and a later application lies before the Calcutta High Court. Anticipatory bail is not excluded by the section's name. It is granted sparingly when the accusation is grave, the injury is serious, and custody is shown to be necessary. It is not refused only because the section number is 307.
On a regular bail application the court looks at the FIR, the injury papers, the role given to each accused, any recovery, antecedents, and the likelihood of the accused absconding or leaning on witnesses. Parity with a co-accused who has bail is a factor, not a rule, where the roles differ. Long custody without a charge sheet is a factor under the general law on the progress of investigation. None of these factors guarantees an order.
Conditions, if bail is granted, commonly include a bond, appearance, a direction not to enter the locality of the injured person for a stated period, and sometimes surrender of a passport. A condition to pay the injured person's bills can be contested if it is being used as a back-door punishment. Breach of a condition is a ground to cancel bail. It is not a conviction.
The sessions court that grants bail is not framing the charge on that day. Charge is framed later, after committal, on the material the prosecution then has. An argument that "the charge will fail" is noted. It is not decided as if the bail hearing were the trial.
Settlement and the High Court's limited power
Compromise quashing is not a right. Section 307 ipc is outside the compounding table, so the trial court cannot acquit on a deed alone. The High Court's inherent power, now in Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, is different. In Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab (2014) the Supreme Court said the High Court may look at a genuine settlement in a prosecution under this section, but must examine whether the facts show a serious attempt or a quarrel that was over-charged. State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan (2019) tightened that guidance. The power is used sparingly. Where the injury, the weapon and the role show a real attempt to kill, a settlement is not a ground to stop the prosecution.
The Supreme Court has limited compromise quashing in prosecutions of this kind to cases that are, on their facts, more private than heinous. A neighbourhood scuffle with a minor hurt, booked under the attempt section, is the sort of file in which the argument is even open. A repeated assault with a sharp weapon is the sort of file in which the argument is ordinarily closed. The High Court reads the papers. It does not take the section number as the only fact, and it does not take the deed as the only fact.
A settlement obtained by pressure, or signed because bail was withheld until money changed hands, is not the settlement those judgments describe. The court can refuse to act on it. Parties should not be told that paying a sum will produce an acquittal. The statute does not say that.
How an attempt case moves in Kolkata
The first production after arrest is before a Magistrate. If the case is committed, the trial is before a Court of Session. City sessions work and the sessions divisions in the metropolitan area are allocated by notification and by the place of the incident. Alipore and Bankshall name different parts of that structure. The summons names the court. That name, not a general reference to the city, goes into the bail application.
A petition invoking the High Court's inherent power, or a bail application after the Court of Session has refused, is filed in the Calcutta High Court. The roster changes. The filing requirements for a settlement petition, including the presence of the injured person, are checked against the current practice direction rather than against memory.
Section 307 ipc is the same text in Kolkata as in any other sessions division. The local difference is the court, the calendar, and which hospital's papers are in the file. Section 109 bns does not become a city rule. It applies when the date of the act brings the new code into play, here as elsewhere.
Need help with a matter of this kind in Kolkata?
Our Kolkata office can look at the papers you already have.
Lawfy & Co. Kolkata Office
Speak to Our Kolkata Team
If you need guidance on the subject of this note, call or WhatsApp the Lawfy & Co. Kolkata office. Share the basic facts and the documents you have, and the team will explain the possible next steps.
Contacting the office does not by itself create an advocate-client relationship.
4ES8 Mani Casadona, Newtown, Street No. 372, Action Area II, Kolkata, West Bengal 700156
Phone: +91 91471 09222
Email: ask@lawfyco.in
WhatsApp: +91 91471 09222
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the victim have to die for this charge to be made out?
No. The section punishes the act and the mental element. Survival, including survival because of treatment, does not by itself reduce the charge to hurt. The court still has to find the murder standard of mind. Section 307 ipc is an attempt provision, not a result provision.
What is the maximum sentence?
If hurt is caused, imprisonment for life is open, or the lesser term. If no hurt is caused, the maximum is lower. For an act on or after 1 July 2024, section 109 bns carries the same split. The life-convict limb is cited only when that custody status is a fact in the case.
Can the parties settle and end the case?
Not before the trial court, because the offence is outside the compounding table. The High Court has a narrow power to stop a prosecution on a genuine settlement, and only where the facts are not a serious attempt. A deed is not an acquittal.
Where is bail moved?
Before committal, bail is ordinarily moved in the sessions court, because of the maximum punishment. A further application lies before the Calcutta High Court. The Magistrate's power is limited where imprisonment for life is open. Each order is on that file's papers.
हिंदी सवाल-जवाब
पीड़ित के बच जाने से क्या यह धारा नहीं बनती?
नहीं। यह धारा मृत्यु का परिणाम नहीं, बल्कि काम और मन की स्थिति देखती है। इलाज से जान बच जाना, अपने आप में, आरोप को साधारण चोट नहीं बना देता। हत्या जैसा मन सिद्ध होना अभी भी जरूरी है।
समझौते से मुकदमा खत्म हो जाता है?
ट्रायल अदालत में नहीं, क्योंकि यह अपराध समझौते की सूची में नहीं है। उच्च न्यायालय कुछ मामलों में असली समझौते पर मुकदमा रोक सकता है, जब तथ्य गंभीर प्रयास न दिखाते हों। लिखी हुई रसीद बरी करना नहीं है।
जमानत कहाँ माँगी जाती है?
आमतौर पर सत्र न्यायालय में, क्योंकि सजा आजीवन कारावास तक जा सकती है। वहाँ से इनकार के बाद कलकत्ता उच्च न्यायालय में अर्जी हो सकती है। जमानत न तो धारा के नाम से रुकती है और न अपने आप मिलती है।
The information in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is formed by reading this content.

