Legal Insights

Section 406 IPC (BNS 316): Criminal Breach of Trust (New Delhi)

Section 406 ipc punished criminal breach of trust where property was handed over and later dealt with dishonestly. This note explains the ingredients, the restatement in section 316 bns, and how a court in New Delhi separates that offence from a claim that belongs in a civil court.

2026-11-13 12 min read
Blogs
Section 406 IPC (BNS 316): Criminal Breach of Trust (New Delhi)

Last reviewed: November 2026

A missing payment and a missing trust are not the same fact. Traders, employers, partners and relatives often reach a police station because money or goods have not come back. The penal section applies only when the law's ingredients are present. A contract that has gone sour is frequently a suit for recovery, not a prosecution.

The paragraphs below set out those ingredients, the change in the maximum sentence under the new code, the difference from cheating, and the limited circumstances in which the High Court stops the case. They are general information. They do not predict an order in any one file.

Key Insights

01Section 406 ipc required two things that must still be found in the papers: property handed over in trust, or dominion over it, and a later dishonest dealing with that property. A bare failure to pay is not enough.
02The first ingredient is entrustment, or dominion over property. Without entrustment there is no criminal breach of trust, however sharp the commercial grievance. A sale, a loan, and a trust are not interchangeable words.
03Section 316 bns restates the offence in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. The general maximum is higher than the three years under the old section. Aggravated clauses, for carriers, clerks, public servants and agents, remain heavier. The date of the act decides which text governs the sentence.
04Section 420 is a different offence. It requires deception at the start, which induces delivery of property. A later decision to keep what was lawfully received is the trust offence, not the cheating offence, unless the deception was there from the beginning.
05Where the FIR describes only a price quarrel or a running account, courts have treated the case as a civil dispute given a criminal label. Quashing is used in that situation. It is not used only because the accused would rather face a suit.

A supplier in New Delhi holds an FIR after a buyer kept goods that were sent on approval. Which sentence in the FIR shows that the goods were trusted to him, rather than sold?

Speak to the Lawfy & Co. Delhi team about your matter.

What section 406 ipc requires

Section 406 ipc was the punishment section. The definition sat in Section 405 of the Indian Penal Code. Whoever, being entrusted with property or with dominion over property, dishonestly misappropriates or converts it, or dishonestly uses or disposes of it in violation of a law or a legal contract, or wilfully suffers another person to do so, committed criminal breach of trust. The punishment was imprisonment of either description up to three years, or fine, or both.

Section 316 bns carries the definition and the punishments in one provision. The general clause punishes the offence with imprisonment which may extend to five years, or with fine, or with both. The aggravated clauses follow the old pattern. A carrier, wharfinger or warehouse-keeper, a clerk or servant, and a public servant, banker, merchant, factor, broker, attorney or agent face higher maxima where the property was received in that capacity. The sub-section on the FIR matters, because the maximum controls classification.

For an act before 1 July 2024, the Indian Penal Code still supplies the offence. For an act on or after that date, the new code does. A charge sheet that cites section 406 ipc for a 2025 handing over, or Section 316 for a 2022 handing over, has used the wrong substantive text. The sentence cannot be picked from whichever text looks harsher.

The second ingredient is dishonest misappropriation, conversion, or a use that breaks the law or the contract touching the trust. A loss from price, rejection or a slow payer is not, without dishonest misappropriation, this offence. Dishonestly means an intention to cause wrongful gain or wrongful loss. Holding goods during a quality dispute is not, by itself, conversion.

Dominion, a later dishonest act, and partnership

Dominion means control the owner conferred. The property may be money, goods, or stridhan. In Pratibha Rani v. Suraj Kumar (1985) the Supreme Court held that stridhan given to a husband to be kept can be the subject of section 406 ipc. The judgment does not turn every jewellery quarrel into a prosecution.

In Velji Raghavji Patel v. State of Maharashtra (1965) a partner who receives firm money does not, by that receipt alone, commit the offence. A special agreement creating a trust, distinct from the partnership, is what must be shown. Onkar Nath Mishra v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2008) and S.W. Palanitkar v. State of Bihar (2002) require both ingredients to be alleged, not inferred from a loss. An employee who wilfully lets another remove stock in his dominion can fall inside section 406 ipc. Negligence, without a dishonest omission, does not.

IngredientWhat the paper must showWhat is not enough
Handing overProperty or dominion given to be dealt with in a particular wayA sale, a loan, or a price that was never paid
Later actDishonest conversion, use, or suffering another to do soA delay, a quality dispute, or a loss
MindIntention to cause wrongful gain or wrongful lossAnger after a contract failed
CapacityThe clause: ordinary, carrier, clerk, or public servant or agentA job title with no dominion

Cheating, recovery, and a criminal label

An FIR that adds Section 420 to a later quarrel about accounts has to show deception at the inception, not merely a failure to return. Cheating, and dishonest inducement of delivery of property, looks at the moment the victim parted with the property. Criminal breach of trust looks at a later breach of a trust that began lawfully. The two can appear together when the accused never meant to keep the bargain and also occupied a position of trust. They cannot be stapled together to make a bailable, non-cognizable allegation look more serious.

In Indian Oil Corporation v. NEPC India Ltd. (2006) the Supreme Court warned courts to see through a civil dispute dressed in penal language. A price claim or a running account has a civil remedy. It does not need the language of section 406 ipc.

Vijay Kumar Ghai v. State of West Bengal (2022) quashed a prosecution where the dispute was commercial and the ingredients were absent. Neeharika Infrastructure v. State of Maharashtra (2021) holds the other line: the High Court does not stop an investigation only because the accused calls the matter civil, if the FIR discloses section 406 ipc. The papers decide which line applies.

A money claim is not a faster decree by filing a police complaint. Nor is every commercial FIR thrown out. Under section 406 ipc the test is a handing over plus the later dishonest act, with particulars a court can see.

Sentence, bail and compounding

Under the First Schedule to the old procedure code, section 406 ipc was non-cognizable and bailable, and triable by any Magistrate. Under the old schedule the offence was compoundable with the permission of the court, at the instance of the person to whom the loss was caused. That classification is why many complainants added the cheating section: a non-cognizable case does not, by itself, authorise arrest without a warrant or an FIR in the same way as a cognizable case. Adding a section the facts do not support is a defect, not a strategy the court has to bless.

Whether the successor offence is compoundable is a question for the table in Section 359 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, read against the exact clause charged. A higher maximum can also change whether the offence is cognizable and whether bail is a matter of right. Copying the old schedule onto section 316 bns is an error. The schedule in force, and the sub-section, are what the bail application cites.

Where section 406 ipc is bailable, bail is claimed as of right on bond. Where the schedule makes the charged clause non-bailable, the court looks at the allegation, roots, tampering, and whether custody is needed to trace the property. A deposit condition is not automatic, and it is not a civil decree.

Compounding, where the table allows it, is done before the court, with the person named in the table as the person who may compound. A private receipt signed at a police station is not, by itself, a composition. If the court allows composition, the effect under the old Section 320, and under the successor provision, is an acquittal on that charge. A charge that is outside the table is not ended by a receipt. It may still be the subject of a petition to quash if the settlement and the nature of the offence justify that course. That is a separate jurisdiction.

When the High Court stops the prosecution

Quashing, under what is now Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, follows State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal (1992). The FIR is read to see whether, taken at face value, it discloses the offence. Missing particulars of who handed over what, and when the dishonest act occurred, are the usual gaps. A petition that asks the High Court to believe the accused's ledger over the complainant's ledger is asking for a trial in the wrong forum.

Quashing is refused where the ingredients are present and the defence is a factual denial. It is also refused, at the investigation stage, where Neeharika applies and the police have not yet collected the documents. The accused's remedy then is to cooperate, to produce the contract and the account, and to seek bail if custody is sought. Destroying invoices after the FIR is not a defence. It is a fact about conduct.

A parallel civil suit does not, by itself, bar the prosecution. Equally, a pending prosecution does not, by itself, bar the suit. The two can run when both are properly framed. The abuse is a prosecution under section 406 ipc with no handing over and no dishonest act, filed to press a money claim. Courts have called that an abuse. They have not abolished the offence.

A breach of trust allegation in New Delhi

A complaint in the city is filed before the Magistrate who has jurisdiction, generally where the property was handed over or where the dishonest act took place. The police station named on a cognizable FIR, if one is registered because of the sections actually cited, is the unit on the notice. A later petition goes to the Delhi High Court. The roster and the filing counter change, so the cause list for the week is the document to check.

District courts, including Patiala House, Tis Hazari, Saket, Dwarka, Karkardooma and Rouse Avenue, divide work by territory. The police station or the place of handing over picks the district. Section 406 ipc is not a different offence because the district is different.

Section 406 ipc is read the same way in New Delhi as elsewhere. What changes is the forum, the notification that fixes which Magistrate takes a complaint, and the time a petition actually takes to be listed. A draft that cites section 316 bns for an old act, or the old punishment section for a new act, is corrected before filing, not after a defect is pointed out in court.

Need help with a matter of this kind in Delhi?

Our Delhi office can look at the papers you already have.

Lawfy & Co. Delhi Office

Speak to Our Delhi Team

If you need guidance on the subject of this note, call or WhatsApp the Lawfy & Co. Delhi office. Share the basic facts and the documents you have, and the team will explain the possible next steps.

Contacting the office does not by itself create an advocate-client relationship.

N-103, N Block, Greater Kailash I, New Delhi, Delhi 110048

Phone: +91 91471 09222

Email: ask@lawfyco.in

WhatsApp: +91 91471 09222

Frequently Asked Questions

Is every unpaid invoice a breach of trust?

No. The owner must have handed the property over to be dealt with in a particular way, and the accused must then have dealt with it dishonestly. A buyer who does not pay the price of goods sold has broken a contract. That is a suit, unless a separate trust is alleged with particulars.

Which text applies after July 2024?

An act before 1 July 2024 is an offence under the Indian Penal Code if the ingredients are met. An act on or after that date is read under the new penal code. Section 316 bns is the provision for the later act. The procedure for a step taken now follows the procedure code in force, subject to its savings clause.

Does a settlement at the police station end the case?

A receipt is evidence of a payment. It becomes a composition only if the offence is in the statutory table and the court permits it, where permission is required. A charge outside that table is not ended by a private paper.

Can the High Court quash the FIR because a civil suit is pending?

Not for that reason alone. The High Court looks at whether the FIR discloses the ingredients. A suit and a properly framed prosecution can both exist. A prosecution that only repeats a money claim, with no trust and no dishonest act, is the one courts have stopped.

हिंदी सवाल-जवाब

भुगतान न करना क्या अपने आप में आपराधिक न्यासभंग है?

नहीं। संपत्ति किसी खास तरीके से रखने या इस्तेमाल करने के लिए सौंपी गई हो, और बाद में बेईमानी से उसका उपयोग हुआ हो, तभी यह अपराध बनता है। केवल बिल का बकाया दीवानी मुकदमे का विषय है।

नई संहिता में सज़ा क्या है?

सामान्य रूप में कैद पाँच साल तक, या जुर्माना, या दोनों हो सकती है। पुरानी धारा में सामान्य अधिकतम तीन साल था। वाहक, मुंशी, लोक सेवक या अभिकर्ता जैसी हैसियत पर अलग और भारी उपधाराएँ हैं। घटना की तारीख तय करती है कि पुराना पाठ लगेगा या नया।

दिल्ली में याचिका कहाँ जाती है?

शिकायत क्षेत्राधिकार वाले मजिस्ट्रेट के यहाँ होती है। प्राथमिकी रद्द कराने की याचिका दिल्ली उच्च न्यायालय में जाती है। किस जिले की अदालत लेगी, यह थाने या सौंपे जाने के स्थान से तय होता है।

The information in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is formed by reading this content.