GST disputes in India cluster around a few questions: whether input tax credit was available, whether the supply was classified correctly, and whether the department followed the demand procedure. The tax is national. The litigation is still local, because the notice, the reply, and the first appeal are handled by the officers of the Centre or the state that issued the notice.
Input tax credit
Section 16 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 sets the conditions for credit. A invoice, receipt of goods or services, tax actually paid by the supplier, and a return by the recipient are the usual conditions. Mismatches between the recipient’s claim and the supplier’s filing are the most common notice. A credit ledger that cannot be tied to invoices, goods-receipt records, and the supplier’s status is difficult to defend. Blocked credits under Section 17(5), including several categories of construction, motor vehicles, and personal consumption, are the second pattern.
Classification and rate
Rate disputes turn on the description of the supply and, for goods, the tariff heading. A product sold for years under one rate can be re-characterised after a change in packaging, a composite contract, or an advance ruling given to someone else in the trade. The reply has to address the heading, the exemption notification, and any binding ruling on that taxpayer. An advance ruling is binding on the applicant and the officers in that state. It is not a national precedent.
How a demand is raised
Sections 73 and 74 of the CGST Act are the main demand provisions. Section 73 applies where there is no allegation of fraud, wilful misstatement, or suppression. Section 74 applies where that allegation is made, and the tax, interest, and penalty consequences are heavier. The show-cause notice has to state the facts, the provision, and the amount. A reply that only argues limitation, or only argues merits, leaves the other point open. Interest and penalty should be answered separately from the tax.
Appeals
The first appeal is to the appellate authority. A further appeal lies to the GST Appellate Tribunal where the tribunal bench for that dispute is functioning, and thereafter to the High Court on substantial questions of law. Pre-deposit rules apply. Missing the limitation period is usually harder to cure than a weak merits argument. Taxpayers who intend to appeal should diarise the date of communication of the order, not the date someone downloaded it from the portal.
Lawfy & Co advises on GST notices, replies, and appeals from Bengaluru, New Delhi, Kolkata, and Surat. This note is general information, not legal advice.

